So, this is a question I have heard from multiple places over the time I’ve been writing, including once from a panel at a writer’s workshop I attended a few years ago, and I have heard multiple answers to it. I’ve even wondered about it myself.
Is Outlining Your Story or Doing it Freehand Better?
Well, I think the answer to that question depends on your personal preferences and which method blends better with your brand of creativity. But I will discuss the pros and cons of both styles and let you decide.
What is Outlining?
Outlining (or plotting) is drawing up a plan for how you want your story or essay to progress before the writing begins in an organized fashion.
It’s like a map you create; instead of being a guide around town, it is a guide to the story or essay in your mind. However, unlike an actual map, you can either stick with it or tweak it as you go.
If it’s an essay, you’d jot down the introduction, main points, supporting evidence, and conclusion. If it’s a book, although there is much overlap in the outlining, instead of supporting evidence, it would be subplots. You also would write down character arcs, plot twists, and whatnot.
Me and Outlining
I don’t prefer this method for my creative stories, as it confines my imagination. Still, I have used it for school assignments to help me narrow my focus to whatever topic I was writing on.
The one exception to me would be when it comes to ghostwriting, creative or not. Since it technically isn’t your story and there are often deadlines, I’d use an outline, whether you have to create it or the person hiring you already has one drawn up.
However, I’ve talked with and heard from some writers who find that an outline’s structure allows them to be creative without getting lost.
Which brings us to freeform writing.
What is Freeform?
Freeform writing (or pantsing) is what you might call organic writing. You let your story write itself through you with what I like to call your writer’s instinct.
This allows you to find cool facts about your story, characters, and more as you develop your story.
On the other hand, freeform writing can cause you to go completely left field in your projects if you’re not careful. Fiction isn’t as big of a deal; although you might veer away from your original idea entirely, depending on the essay, it might not benefit you.
From what I have learned, this is also the method fiction writers tend to lean toward, not all of them, but many.
Me and Freeform
This is the method I use for all my creative pieces, but don’t mistake freeform for not having a plan. I always have an idea about what I want to happen, then go off from there. I like finding out the details as I go.
And I have to say, parts of my stories have taken unexpected and surprising turns along the way that have ultimately added to the overall stories. I’ve discovered exciting subplots, surprise twists that shocked me, and even new characters sometimes.
It brought in opportunities I may have missed out on in an outline. And it was because I didn’t plan it; it naturally happened. So, in other words, freeform is a lot like life.
Writers’ instinct for the win!
So, Which One Wins?
As I said before, it really depends on personal preference.
But please don’t start a fight with someone over this because they may have a different opinion than you since neither is wrong nor right.
Whichever method you prefer, your story or paper will need infrastructure, or else it won’t work. I’ve had a few flop pieces because I had no plans going into them.
You have to have a plan, whether you jot it down in an organized outline or freeform it in your head. Then, you just have to decide how to implement it.
Do you have comments or ideas for future posts or want to collaborate on a piece?
I must say that while freehand and outlines are subject to preference, individuals who want to become proficient at their craft should aim to improve at both.
I find myself using both interchangeably in my own work. I’ll outline for an info-heavy article and freehand for a philosophical analysis. Of course, as you said, both need planning regardless.
This is a great article, especially for those trying to gain more perspective on how writing methodologies affect your results.